2 min read

7NEWS Spotlight: Criminal experts say mushroom killer Erin Patterson ‘knew what she was doing’

Criminal experts have described mushroom killer Erin Patterson as a ‘formidable witness’ who ‘knew what she was doing’.
Jessica EvensenBy Jessica Evensen
Patterson this week was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder, following a mammoth 10-week-long trial. 

7NEWS Spotlight: Criminal experts say mushroom killer Erin Patterson ‘knew what she was doing’

Criminal experts have described mushroom killer Erin Patterson as a ‘formidable witness’ who ‘knew what she was doing’.
Jessica EvensenBy Jessica Evensen

Criminal experts have described mushroom killer Erin Patterson as a “formidable witness” who “knew what she was doing”.

Patterson this week was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder, following a mammoth 10-week-long trial.

The 50-year-old’s estranged husband Simon’s parents, Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after Patterson served them beef Wellington parcels laced with death cap mushrooms in July 2023.

Know the news with the 7NEWS app: Download today Download today

Heather’s husband, Ian Wilkinson, was the sole survivor.

Now, in a 7NEWS Spotlight special, presenter Michael Usher investigates how the seemingly ordinary mother-of-two became one of the worst female mass murderers in Australian history.

Featuring in-depth analysis and expert commentary from industry leaders including criminal barrister Geoffrey Watson, forensic psychologist Peter Ashkar and former detective Damian Marrett, Spotlight dives into the mind of a killer.

Criminal psychologist Peter Ashkar. Credit: Supplied

According to Usher, Mr Ashkar described poisoning someone as an “act of aggression” and said it was a “very deliberate act of control of power”.

“(Being poisoned) is an absolutely hideous way to die because there’s intense pain and suffering,” Usher said.

Mr Ashkar also described Patterson as smart and cunning and said “she knew what she was doing”.

Read more...

“If you look back at the vision of her at her home when our reports went and door-stopped her, (she was) in tears and was distraught and upset,” Usher said.

“But on the stand, Ashkar said she was formidable — she knew what she was doing and she was clear and smart.

Credit: Victoria's Supreme Court/Supplied, the deadly meal Erin Patterson used to kill three members of her husband’s family have been released by Victoria’s Supreme Court.

“(Ashkar said Patterson) knew what was going on, she was in charge and she owned her narrative.

“Getting inside her mind is a fascinating and frightening exercise.”

But Usher said Patterson didn’t appear to have a clear motive.

“We’re so used to murder cases (where there is a) very clear motive like revenge, fame or money,” he said.

“It’s not like she had a proven pattern (of saying), ‘I hate my in laws, they have done me wrong, I want to plan something’, it wasn’t as clear as that.”

Inside the Mind of the Mushroom Killer: A 7NEWS Spotlight special airs Sunday at 8.45pm

Stream free on

7plus logo

More from

ACCC’s bitter pill for $8.8b Sigma, Chemist Warehouse union

Australia’s competition regulator has raised a raft of red flags over Sigma Healthcare’s proposed $8.8 billion tie-up with Chemist Warehouse that is set to catapult the private retailer onto the ASX.

4 min read

Dutton’s age ban to save kids from ‘industrial scale’ evil

Australian children under 16 would be banned from social media under a Coalition government, according to Opposition Leader Peter Dutton.

4 min read

Picking Trell for Origin II a no-brainer

KIERSTEN DUKE: He is Queensland’s worst nightmare so Michael Maguire needs to swallow his pride and choose Latrell Mitchell. Plus the women’s Origin thriller was great even if the Maroons won.

3 min read

Same job, same pay fight for 1700 workers at BHP coal mines

BHP could be hit with orders to lift the pay packets of 1700 labour hire workers at three of its Queensland coal mines as the Mining and Energy Union pursues the miner under new Same Job, Same Pay laws.

2 min read

7NEWS presenters go to war over State of Origin

7NEWS Sydney started the battle but their Brisbane counterparts returned serve with two brutal words.

2 min read

Neighbour recalls woman’s harrowing final moments in Sydney gas explosion

An elderly man has revealed his desperate efforts to rescue a woman trapped after the explosion on Saturday.

2 min read

Teen driver admits to killing SA top cop’s son in schoolies tragedy

A young driver has made a surprise admission following the death of an 18-year-old man.

2 min read

The latest on Suzuki Jimny wait times in Australia

Suzuki Australia has detailed current wait times for its ever-popular Jimny 4x4 range, with up to eight-month delays for some variants.

2 min read

Alleged killer’s chilling account of schoolgirl’s last words

The girl’s body was found dumped four days after she was reported missing.

3 min read

2024 Kia EV6 deals: Finance offer joins crowd of EV deals

Kia is offering sharper financing deals on the two most expensive members of its EV6 electric crossover range.

1 min read

Jury told Greg Lynn cannot be convicted of manslaughter

The instruction means the former Jetstar pilot can only be convicted or acquitted of murder when the jury deliberates.

1 min read

7NEWS Poll: What we don’t like about the Blues

Ahead of State of Origin I, NSW has put out a savage list of what they dislike about Queensland. Now it’s time to return fire.

1 min read